There is a small but telling detail on Clara Mann’s Bandcamp profile: in the ‘About’ section, under Mann’s photograph and the bare details of her new album (title, release date) is the short descriptor ‘almost-folk music’. It’s nearly nothing, but spend any time with Mann’s music, and you’ll realise it’s important. For all their low-lit stillness and surface clarity, her songs seem constantly to be moving towards or away from something intangible, existing in a shifting, restless state that might present as physical movement (she has written more than one song that mentions train travel and departure) or as a changing perspective on something like love or desire. On her earlier songs – on last year’s debut album Rift and the singles and EP that preceded it – this state of almost-being was tied up with a certain introspection, perhaps even an anxiety born from the tension of perpetual suspension between two places or emotional states.
On Wishbone, she has embraced the things that previously unsettled her, finding happiness in tension and opening herself up to new experiences; the result is an album of greater breadth and expertise. Greater emotional maturity too, perhaps. Her strongest instrument is her voice, and it has flourished with a newfound confidence: the emotion of old is still there, but she has found new ways to shape it to her will. Her songwriting has become more varied too. On The Izaak Walton Hotel, accompanied by gentle piano, she details how a haunting experience in a Peak District country house hotel helped ease her out of a period of dissociation, while on Connie’s Song she examines her own desire to disappear through the lens of Connie Converse, the pioneering songwriter who is still legally classed as a missing person after leaving her family and friends a series of cryptic notes and vanishing in 1974. ‘Nobody can make me settle down’, Mann sings, simultaneously memorialising Converse and finding strength in her own rootlessness. It’s a quiet and powerful kind of songwriting.
She can still be stark and uncompromising, even when starting from a position of apparent positivity. On Oblivion, she stares into a void created by falling in love. To a minimal, dark-hued backdrop of viola and acoustic guitar, she ventures into increasingly philosophical and emotionally complex lyrical territory. She recognises the darkness inherent in every situation; the difference between now and the Clara Mann of old is that she moves towards that darkness, embraces it, and begins to form a dialogue with it. Another song about falling in love – about its ambiguities, its heart-fluttering moments of change and recognition, and about the way love forces you to redefine your ideas of closeness and openness. If newfound proximity to another person can be a terrifying thing, as Oblivion attests, it can also be liberating and revelatory.
This album is all about those moments of revelation, and Mann exposes them in different ways. News From Home – a song that feels like it was summoned into being in the limpid morning light – employs a nostalgic melody and softly plucked guitar, while All My Devotion proceeds on a soft percussive shuffle and slow, wandering piano. Her singing, with its emphasis on hushed sibilants, has something of Laura Marling about it, only more restrained, more suited to darker hours and deep thoughts. The meandering, discursive nature of her songs means that structure often dissolves, or at least seems to, but there is always an underlying logic, which is discernibly the logic of love. One aspect of love is romantic, another is something closer to friendship, and is linked to recovery. Mann writes about recovery brilliantly, both in The Izaak Walton Hotel and in Go Getter, a song that recognises how a kind word from a friend can turn a low point into a turning point.
Primarily, though, these songs discuss the onset of a romantic relationship, and Mann has a great ear for the language of touch and physical nearness, like a downbeat sister to Kath Bloom. And she is not immune to the urge towards gentle irony, as she shows in I’m Everyone Who’s Ever Said I Love You, which channels both sophisticated Laurel Canyon country-folk and naive Lesley Duncan-esque pop. The simple acoustic guitar of Song For Joy has something of Leonard Cohen about it, but the song’s central premise – ‘good things will find me wherever I am’ – moves beyond the usual Cohen-esque melancholy, towards the light of contentment.
With Wishbone, Clara Mann has developed her art into something like the musical equivalent of chiaroscuro, the mastery of the contrast between darkness and light, and all possible gradations in between. It is an album that reveals its many lyrical and melodic secrets freely but carefully, encouraging close listening and personal engagement in a way that is becoming all too rare. A beautiful, slowed-down take on chamber-folk, it deserves and rewards the minutest attention.
Wishbone (OCtober 23rd, 2026) state51
