David Kidman
David Kidman
I've written for several music publications (online and print-based, national and regional) for a while now! Outside of this activity, I'm a revival singer/song-carrier; also a sometime performance poet, and compère of folk music events (and I've occasionally been roped in for a bit of radio presenting). Living in a comparatively rural part of the country helps to keep me sane!
The fire and fury and commitment of Planxty as a hell of a performing unit is there in full force. Live sets are by their nature usually best aimed at the converted, but for someone outside of the established Planxty fan-base One Night In Bremen certainly steers closer into the “worth acquiring” category than the majority of live releases.
I can’t fault the playing here one jot, nor indeed the production quality of Volunteer, nor for that matter the songs themselves which clearly display both affection and craft. But I’m left with a nagging feeling that there’s more than a hint of contrivance, “adopting a role” and being all things to all listeners with this album.